As Redheadcurly2007 mentioned above, you can also get it at Indian grocery stores (and there must be quite a few of them in NY). We have one here and I bought one especially for hair called "Medimix" with herbs that help hair growth, there's also "Dabur Vatika" of which I read many good reviews not long ago. Even a regular one (that's not refined) like "Parachute" is fine.
Also, most malls have a "Vitamin World" store and they carry Extra Virgin c.o. in a 1lb. tub.