Hmm, then I'm stumped. Those are good products with some weight to them. Only thing I can think of is that Re:coil is a curl enhancing product, which maybe isn't what you want. Maybe try leaving in a little more One C and skipping the re:coil?

Oh, I see bostoncurl thought of that also, good for you.

Another idea is that for me, using a leave-in seems to work against the hold I get from my gel, so my hair tends to be frizzy. So, on that line of thinking, the other thing I can suggest would be to skip the leave-in entirely and just try the Gelee by itself. It will probably be more crunchy, but it might possibly keep your hair under better control, volume-wise.