Hmm, interesting. I guess it shows that hair doesn't really matter. I get the feeling the girl felt more confident with one style than the other, so I think that made a difference in her results.
The Fair Minstrel Victoria, Keeper of the Celestial Charts and Protector of the Aquamarine Diadem in the Order of the Curly Crusaders

3a/b brunette curls
Modified CG-ish (sulfates, but no cones. Works for me :P)
Cleanse: Suave Coconut shampoo
Condition:Herbal Essences Hello Hydration
Stylers: AG Re:Coil and whatever gel I can find.
Double-plopping, octopus clipping (dry), and recently, diffusing.

To Waist Length!