I have the same dilemma. If my hair is clumpy, I don't have as much volume. I go back and forth with clumping and not clumping. I do like your first two pics the best. I think your pics actually have helped me decide to stick with trying to be clumpy.
Started CG July 8, 2008


Pre Co-wash: Coconut oil (plain & rosemary)
Co-wash: Trader Joe's Tea Tree Tingle or Trader Joe's Nourish Spa
Rinse out: GVP Conditioning Balm
Leave-in/Styling: Moisture Maniac with Kenra Moisturizing Conditioner on top