I agree with many of you.
Yes, it can work as long as you are respectful, and at least on the same page. If you are more of a strict religious, and go to church every week, and want someone to do the same with you... You probably shouldn't date an atheist.
That said, I have dated one religious guy in the past 20 years. He was the right type of religious for me. He believes church is/can be sitting by a river. The rest of my boyfriends were atheist, or didn't really know what they believed yet. We never had problems due to religious/spiritual differences. I have never been the type to conform someone to my thoughts or beliefs.
When I hear terms like "hipster" I think, who told cliques they could leave high school??