I have super-sensitive skin. I have gotten pink bumps under my eyes from several "gentle" eye creams. I currently use Chagrin Valley's Eye Mousse
- basically the most delicious, gentle thing I've ever put on my face. It is rich without being greasy, and makes my eyes feel soothed even in drying allergy season. I use it morning and night, and it doesn't make my eye makeup slide around (though I wear very minimal makeup). It takes a little while to "sink in," so I let it do that for about 20-30 minutes between applying and putting on my makeup. I just get dressed and feed the dog, etc.
I have minimal 30something lines at the corners of my eyes, and between this and Clarins eye sunscreen, they have diminished a bit over the past month.