Great Lash didn't work for me either, or any of the other Maybelline favorites. The Falsies, etc. One of the newer Rocket mascaras is okay. I wear it from time to time with no remorse, but no excitement either.
Sorry you have not been having luck, CP. Can you return some of these items? I would he marching back to BB counter for sure. Maybe you can tone down the chubby with a lighter gloss?.?.