I've never tried AG: Recoil but I loooove the B&A gel! I like it now and I was loving it in the winter too. Because you say "on dry days" I'm wondering if people will vote for the cream but I still say get the B&A gel!!
2b/3a, primarily use Jessicurl and DevaCurl products, Curls Hair Tea conditioner and various gels. I'm modified CG-ish since 5/04.