I want to try meow cosmetics too, but I'm also overwhelmed by the selection! I think I'm a neutral. I can wear almost any color and look fine, but I look great in fall shades and bright colors. The only color that doesn't look good is yellow, but I can wear gold just fine. Both silver and gold jewelry looks fine.
and I'm waaaaay pale. There are a few drugstore lines I can't use because they don't come pale enough. When I have money, I'll have to just order up some samples and see what I like. *sigh*