It was the Curls NE lotion.
Thank you so much for your opinoins(and compliments) so far. Since POTAR was winning the last time I checked I decided to use it again for Valentine's Day(it's been a while since I've used it and I forgot what my hair looked like). The gel left my hair shiny, had good hold, and my hair was very curly. I just seem to have a lot of "skinny" curls when I use it. I prefer clumpy curls but I guess I'm just being greedy. POTAR gel is also the one product I just ran out of.