Yeah, he does seem really down-to-earth. I agree that he may not "hot" but he's attractive and sexy. He just seems like a cool guy.
Matthew McConaughey is okay-looking. From a purely aesthetic standpoint, he doesn't do it for me. I guess I typically like a different type. Add to it that he makes me think of the old Seinfeld term: mimbo (male bimbo), and he really doesn't do it for me.