You know, if your scap really needs the H&S, maybe you should keep using it but cut down on frequency and/or dilute it. If CG doesn't work for your scalp, but you have something that does, there's no use trying to fight that. Do you know about the CWC method? That's where you coat the rest of your hair in conditioner, then wash your scalp, then condition again and/or add your leave in. This might help protect the rest of your hair and keep it moisturized while your scalp gets the wash it needs.
fia 2C/3A-F-iii, sensitive to some proteins
CGish since 10-16-08
Low-poo: Yes to Carrots Daily Pampering Shampoo (1-2x/week)
Rinse outs: Yes to Carrots Pampering Mud Conditioner
Styling: a little bit of leave in and a little bit of KCCC, diffusing
Olive oil DTs, honey rinses in the summer