I am having great success with Curls by Sisters Smith Wet Set Pudding. I've been using it for about 3 weeks now and I have better curls than I've had in a long time! And it's not very expensive, even after you pay shipping. I generally use different products every time I do my hair, but I've been so happy with this that I haven't changed anything in the last several washes. Good luck with finding something you like!
Currently using:
shampoo bars, GVP K-Pak, Abba Pure Gentle Leave-in, Mop curl cream, Babaii Mousse and BRHG