Here's the story...

A few months ago, I purchased the Beautiful Curls Shampoo and Conditioner from Whole Foods, but it dried out my hair, so I returned it. The store said it was fine.
The other day, I bought a beer shampoo and conditioner from Whole Foods (I splurged......) to go CG again because they have great reviews and are super gentle, etc. Well, beer has protein, and I think that might be making my coarse, low porosity hair dry

It felt dry even while I was getting out of the shower, so I just gave up and used Herbal Essences Hello Hydration poo and condish as well as a Suave Whipped Cream Curls Mousse--NONE of which are CG but make my hair look awesome.
I was wondering if I should keep trying the beer stuff or if I should just return it. I feel so bad because I JUST bought it a few days ago, and I've already returned something there before. I was thinking with the money I get back, I can buy some Botticelli Botanicals so I can get customized products that should definitely work for me.
I don't want them to think I am a serial returner...and I really don't want to be a serial returner
Any advice would be awesome! Thank you so much!