CurlTalk

CurlTalk (http://www.naturallycurly.com/curltalk/)
-   General Discussion about Curly Hair (http://www.naturallycurly.com/curltalk/general-discussion-about-curly-hair/)
-   -   stearalkonium chloride (http://www.naturallycurly.com/curltalk/general-discussion-about-curly-hair/81249-stearalkonium-chloride.html)

xcurlyxbellax 07-22-2009 03:59 PM

stearalkonium chloride
 
Hi everyone--I'm hoping some of you lovelies can help me out with this one.

I've been strictly CG for about 9 weeks now (I know, still new, haha). I really love the way that my normally coarse, tangly hair is soft, and much of my hair is starting to curl more. But I'm still trying to figure out products and whatnot. Here's my saga so far:

First my hair went limp, and when I researched my conditioners, I found that one of them was full of protein. Cutting that out, my hair was back to normal and getting curlier. But now the past few days have been blah. My hair's limp and soft. At first I thought it was overconditioned (which might still be the case, not sure), but now after searching through the boards here, I might think it's the stearalkonium chloride (yes, i copied and pasted that) in both my Vo5 conditioners. Now I love the smell and, better yet, I love the inexpensiveness of the Vo5s, but if my hair is just going to keep going limp like this, I don't think I can use it. Can anyone tell me a good cheap conditioner that doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride in it? I did a quick check through some of the vo5s and suaves ingredients lists, but I couldn't find any without that ingredient in it (unless i'm just not looking hard enough).

Just as a note, I'm going to pick up GVP Conditioning Balm from Sally's later on (I figure it's time to start experimenting with non-drugstore brands, hah), and the GVPCB doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride...but does that mean all of the cheaper conditioners do have that ingredient in it?

Sorry for the long post--I'm an English major, so it's habit to write a ton. :oops:

Hedy 07-22-2009 04:12 PM

Suave green apple
L'oreal nutigloss for wavy hair
sally beauty's detangler
trader joe's conditioners

xcptnl 07-22-2009 07:23 PM

My hair does not like that ingredient either. I can use a conditioner as a cowash with it in it but not as a rinse out.

I am pretty sure the Sauve Coconut condish does not have that ingredient nor the Wild Cherry. But those have Cetrimonium Chloride which sometimes my hair does not like either. But again, I am ok using them as a cowash just not as a rinse out.

xcurlyxbellax 07-23-2009 01:54 AM

Thank you so much for the ideas...I'll definitely try to find those at the store!

Ceallachg 07-23-2009 06:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xcptnl (Post 1037294)
My hair does not like that ingredient either. I can use a conditioner as a cowash with it in it but not as a rinse out.

I am pretty sure the Sauve Coconut condish does not have that ingredient nor the Wild Cherry. But those have Cetrimonium Chloride which sometimes my hair does not like either. But again, I am ok using them as a cowash just not as a rinse out.

Suave conditioners including the coconut all have three different kinds of chlorides in them (cetrimonium chloride, potassium chloride and distearyldimonium chloride), and my hair became limp and stringy with them, too. I stopped using them altogether, but maybe I'll start using them only for co-washing again, if it works for you. They're too cheap not to try!

mpgirl 07-23-2009 07:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xcurlyxbellax (Post 1037040)
Hi everyone--I'm hoping some of you lovelies can help me out with this one.

I've been strictly CG for about 9 weeks now (I know, still new, haha). I really love the way that my normally coarse, tangly hair is soft, and much of my hair is starting to curl more. But I'm still trying to figure out products and whatnot. Here's my saga so far:

First my hair went limp, and when I researched my conditioners, I found that one of them was full of protein. Cutting that out, my hair was back to normal and getting curlier. But now the past few days have been blah. My hair's limp and soft. At first I thought it was overconditioned (which might still be the case, not sure), but now after searching through the boards here, I might think it's the stearalkonium chloride (yes, i copied and pasted that) in both my Vo5 conditioners. Now I love the smell and, better yet, I love the inexpensiveness of the Vo5s, but if my hair is just going to keep going limp like this, I don't think I can use it. Can anyone tell me a good cheap conditioner that doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride in it? I did a quick check through some of the vo5s and suaves ingredients lists, but I couldn't find any without that ingredient in it (unless i'm just not looking hard enough).

Just as a note, I'm going to pick up GVP Conditioning Balm from Sally's later on (I figure it's time to start experimenting with non-drugstore brands, hah), and the GVPCB doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride...but does that mean all of the cheaper conditioners do have that ingredient in it?

Sorry for the long post--I'm an English major, so it's habit to write a ton. :oops:

Stearalkonium chloride is used in many conditioners, cheap or not, for it's anti-static, surfactant and antimicrobial properties.

Why would your hair go limp from protein? Protein sensitivities usually make your hair immediately straw-like, hard and brittle, not limp. If you think you have a coarse texture, there is usually no doubt when you react to proteins. Limp hair is a symptom of over conditioning and or lack of protein.

xcurlyxbellax 07-23-2009 01:45 PM

Quote:

Why would your hair go limp from protein? Protein sensitivities usually make your hair immediately straw-like, hard and brittle, not limp. If you think you have a coarse texture, there is usually no doubt when you react to proteins. Limp hair is a symptom of over conditioning and or lack of protein.
Oh my goodness, I'm so confused and I have definite information overload...So maybe I don't have to worry about protein, then? All I remember happening is that I had absolutely no curl, and I think I just figured that since a lot of the coarse textures on here had protein sensitivity, so did I.

xcptnl 07-23-2009 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mpgirl (Post 1037787)
Quote:

Originally Posted by xcurlyxbellax (Post 1037040)
Hi everyone--I'm hoping some of you lovelies can help me out with this one.

I've been strictly CG for about 9 weeks now (I know, still new, haha). I really love the way that my normally coarse, tangly hair is soft, and much of my hair is starting to curl more. But I'm still trying to figure out products and whatnot. Here's my saga so far:

First my hair went limp, and when I researched my conditioners, I found that one of them was full of protein. Cutting that out, my hair was back to normal and getting curlier. But now the past few days have been blah. My hair's limp and soft. At first I thought it was overconditioned (which might still be the case, not sure), but now after searching through the boards here, I might think it's the stearalkonium chloride (yes, i copied and pasted that) in both my Vo5 conditioners. Now I love the smell and, better yet, I love the inexpensiveness of the Vo5s, but if my hair is just going to keep going limp like this, I don't think I can use it. Can anyone tell me a good cheap conditioner that doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride in it? I did a quick check through some of the vo5s and suaves ingredients lists, but I couldn't find any without that ingredient in it (unless i'm just not looking hard enough).

Just as a note, I'm going to pick up GVP Conditioning Balm from Sally's later on (I figure it's time to start experimenting with non-drugstore brands, hah), and the GVPCB doesn't have any stearalkonium chloride...but does that mean all of the cheaper conditioners do have that ingredient in it?

Sorry for the long post--I'm an English major, so it's habit to write a ton. :oops:

Stearalkonium chloride is used in many conditioners, cheap or not, for it's anti-static, surfactant and antimicrobial properties.

Why would your hair go limp from protein? Protein sensitivities usually make your hair immediately straw-like, hard and brittle, not limp. If you think you have a coarse texture, there is usually no doubt when you react to proteins. Limp hair is a symptom of over conditioning and or lack of protein.

Also for me that ingredient (if used as a rinse out) can make me limp and lank.

Magoo 07-23-2009 06:10 PM

My hair gets poofy with that ingredient. I can't even use it as a cowash. I get the same reaction with cetrimonium chloride which is also in a lot of the less expensive conditioners. Just a warning that GVP conditioning balm has cet. chloride in it so you may want to keep an eye out for the same reaction.

LexLioness 05-24-2011 11:05 AM

I use Suave coconut as a co-wash, and that has Cetrimonium Chloride in it. I can't say I've ever had a problem with it, but it also doesn't stay in my hair very long.
When I used to also use it as a leave-in, it didn't do a whole lot for my hair - it was pretty frizzy as first day hair and super dry by day 2. I've switched to Giovanni smooth as silk for my leave in, with some FSG on top (how much I use of each depends on the weather). The results are much better that way, and at $7-8 a 8.5oz bottle, I think it's worth it - I've seen conditioners at my store that are up to $18! Yikes...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2011 NaturallyCurly.com