I think I have finally found a routine to combat my oily skin! I am now using Loreal Pure Zone Pore Unclogging Scrub Cleanser and Skin Relief Oil-Free Moisturizer. They both work great! I finally feel like I have my oily skin under control now!
Two notes: I found that I have to use an astringent, too, with these two products for best results. I just used whatever I had under my sink, but I'm sure their astringent would work great, too. I'm going to try it the next time I go skincare shopping. Also, I found that I have to use all three products--cleanser, astringent, and moisturizer--twice a day. If I skip one (like not use the moisturizer at night, which I am not used to doing) my skin will be a little oilier the next day.
Overall, this stuff is amazing. No shine, and no grease throughout the day. Plus my makeup, especially my blush, has been staying on longer throughout the day since my skin isn't as oily.
Much thanks to Twirly Girl for the recommendation!