I don't know how well it would work for lining the rim of you eye but I really like Loreal HIP Color Rich Cream Crayon. It stays on really well. It is a little more expensive (about 8 I think) but I really like it.
Hair Type: mix of 3's, growing out an angled bob, color-treated red.
Current products: GVP conditioning balm for co-wash and leave in, Curl Junkie Curls in a Bottle, Pattern Pusha and Garnier Anti-humidity hairspray
Hair idol: Kimberly Schlapman from Little Big Town