Apologies, I have not had time to go back and read the whole thread.

I have hereditary undereye circles. I have had them since I was very young. A combination of thin skin around the eyes and the shape of my eyes creating shadows.

My problem is that now when I wear concealer, it makes lines around my eyes appear, . When I don't have concealer on, you can't see any lines around my eyes at all. So the concealer makes me look even older.

I don't wear foundation because foundation ages me and I like a natural look. I have freckles and I don't like to hide them.

So my concealer has to be close to my natural skin tone.

Does anyone else have the problem of having to choose between dark circles and lines? Have you found any products that help?