Gardenofwisdom has several castile cleansers that would work...just look for the ones with the 5.5 pH. 's castile is good too.

I've been using the PSF foaming cleanser for a couple weeks now. I like it...I REALLY like it. My skin is better than ever. But, it is expensive for how quickly I'll go through it, because I have to wash with it at least twice to get all my makeup off.

I haven't tried the bar yet.