I have the same problem. I have used 2 that have worked well (well meaning that I use very little cover up);

Serious Skin Care vitamin c eye (it is very nice) not drying at all. Moisture without grease and I don't get puffy from it in the morning (I get puffy if I use an oily type product). www.hsn.com

Derma-E alpha lipoic acid, ester c, eye cream (or lotion; not sure which it is) Nice product as well. get it in health food stores or at www.vitaminshoppe.com