I read this post and decided to test this out and I found that the Yes to Carrots worked just like the One Condition does on my hair. I also found that the Yes to Carrots worked well as a leave-in when I used no product as opposed to the One Conditioner which sometimes frizzes out my hair when I don't use a gel afterwards. (I think that's because of the glycerin.) I am not a HUGE fan of the scent. I prefer the smell of the One Condition but that's just my personal opinion. I don't find the Yes to Carrots scent unpleasant at all though. Unless I find a different conditioner, I may keep using the Yes to Carrots and not repurchase the One Condition because it is very pricey!