I have ordered more than a few things from the second etsy seller you listed and have been completely satisfied with everything!

I like that they make the sticks in different colors and lengths.

These are the only sticks/forks that have ever worked for my hair!
I love Jessicurl HCC, Jessicurl Too Shea, KCKT, KCCC, CK and HESMU...but it took a LOT of trial error to get to these products that consistently work for ME.