-   General Discussion about Curly Hair(
-   -   what are the negatives of the CG routine?(

butterfly72 04-18-2007 03:04 PM

what are the negatives of the CG routine?
see subject line :lol:

JuicyTube 04-18-2007 03:25 PM

I guess some could also take this as positive, but there is a major cut in the number of products that you would want to try!

2bforme 04-18-2007 03:40 PM

It makes my hair way too soft and overconditioned. I actually do a lo-poo most days and a co-wash only about once a week. I cleanse daily. My hair is very thick but fine and it will get weighed down very easily and look like crap if I don't.

kdcreigh 04-18-2007 03:58 PM

For me, it was too stressful. I was obsessive about what was in the products that I wanted to try.

I've fallen off of the CG wagon! :lol:

Now I only avoid products that have cyclopentosiloxane or large amounts of silicones - high in the the 'ingredients' list.

medusahair 04-18-2007 04:21 PM

The stress of finding the right products

Over conditioning

more frizz (for me anyway)

Having to explain to people that you dont' wash with shampoo

Trying to find a balance between flat and greasy and bouncy curly

Oh and the cult like mentality some get (not all so don't bother cursing me out just assume it's not you :D unless it is you hehe)

There are some pluses but the products now are so changed from when she wrote the book. Heck even she makes products that break the CG rules.

tycho19 04-18-2007 05:50 PM

For me, my scalp never felt clean. My hair always felt stringy by the end of the day. I do much better shampooing every other day with elucence, and conditioning the heck out of it with Jessicurl Too Shea.

Ladydncing 04-18-2007 06:46 PM

If you don't use the right products, Buildup!

meriellyn 04-19-2007 02:01 AM

- The initial part of finding the right products. But once you do, it's fabulous.

- The strain of accepting that you may need to modify it to your own hair's needs. At first it may feel like you're breaking *the* rules but you have to realize that it's all about what your hair needs, not what anyone else thinks it should.

- Explaining it to other people. People are bound to ask what you're doing differently to make your hair so lovely. You end up coming up with an explaination that doesn't start with "well, I don't shampoo" because that freaks most people out. Finding the right way to explain it takes some time.

- Once again, finding the right products/routine.

- Eventually, overconditioning. Realizing that your hair may not need that much moisture anymore. Then finding the right products again. :P

- Controlling your inner product junkie once you do find the right products!!

- Finding the right clarifier without resorting to sulfates. (Go ACV and sulfate free 'poo (etc) before you go back to sulfates!!!! Learn to "wash" just your scalp. There's a definite learning curve there but you'll get it eventually. It's a miracle once you do. That one thing can make or break it.)

The pros are totally worth the cons though. :)

bostonwaves 04-19-2007 09:36 AM

The inconsitency of how my hair looks. different everyday.

st. louis blue 04-19-2007 09:50 AM

Well, CG makes my hair more curly, which is not always what I am looking for. But the two main negatives for me are (1) I no longer have any fun in the beauty aisles, because 99.9% of the products are off limits; and (2) without sulfates and silicones, whatever is in the water seems to have much more impact on how my hair looks.

redcelticcurls 04-19-2007 10:34 AM

Good Question! People should be aware of te downsides along with the positives.

As others have said, it does take the fun out of browsing the hair care aisle at most stores. So many things become off limits. But, as better silicones are developed, I think that fewer people need to go totally cone free than, say, twenty years ago. Some can handle the water soluble cones, or cones that come out with a CO wash or a Low-Poo type of cleanser.

I never noticed a protein sensitivity until after I had been cg for a little while. It got worse as I went on. I have wondered that if I went back to some sort of mild sulfate, could I handle more protein and have fewer limits on what kind of conditioners I can use.

The militancy of some cg-ers. Just because it works for some doesn't mean that everyone has to follow it the same way that a lecturing militant wants you to follow it. Everyone has to find out what works best for her.

With my hair texture, I've not had to worry about the overconditioning thing that others wrote, but it does seem to be a fairly common side effect.

meriellyn 04-19-2007 04:20 PM


Originally Posted by bostonwaves
The inconsitency of how my hair looks. different everyday.

I get that anyway regardless of my routine. It's always unpredictable.

And I don't think it takes the fun out of browsing the hair care isles because I was never happy with any of that stuff anyway.

Also, I agree that it's not for everyone. Nothing is.

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:40 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2011